“DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE?!”

curriebelle:

I reblogged a post earlier today talking about how some movies are actually much better than the books they are derived from, and it got me thinking about this infamous moment from Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. Now, I really love thinking about media, and one of my pet projects is the translation of stories from one medium to another.

One of my pet peeves is when people sink into that “the books are better” mentality, often condemning the movies simply because they changed things from the books

This line is a great example of this mentality in action. It’s one of those things that bothers people immensely about the Goblet of Fire movie. People don’t like this particular line for one simple reason. In the book, the scene goes like this:

“Did you put your name in the Goblet of Fire, Harry?” Dumbledore asked calmly.” (pg 242, GoF)

While in the movie, Michael Gambon grabs Harry by the shoulder, asks him the question quite angrily – almost shouting – and shakes him as he does. Here’s the scene and its lead-up so you know I’m not trying to misrepresent it.

Fans like to hold this moment up as emblematic of how the Harry Potter movies don’t understand the characters – e.g., they think Dumbledore is angry and panicky while he’s much calmer in the books. I think this moment is emblematic of how people don’t understand how adaptations work.

Keep reading


Tags:

#Harry Potter #meta #I have no strong opinions regarding the actual argument here but #anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog #discourse cw?

{{previous post in sequence}}


cosmic-llin:

So my friend purplefringe and I got kind of obsessed with THIS POST about folks on DS9 complaining, and spent some time (that we should have been working) imagining it in a bit more detail:

@staff anti-gravity malfunctioning on the promenade again. Request immediate assistance!
@jumalsjumja Hello Jumal this is Intern T’Pok. I have logged your case in our system. You are number #103 in the queue. Your request will be dealt with shortly. Thank you for your patience.
@staff thanks!! any idea how long it will be out this time?
@staff only last time all my jumja sticks got stuck everywhere
@staff NEW REPORT help a nest of voles has just floated out past my stall. This definitely violates health and safety!
@jumalsjumja Hello Jumal this is Intern T’Pok. I have logged your case in our system. You are number #104 in the queue. Your request will be dealt with shortly. Thank you for your patience.
***
@chiefofops Chief the anti-grav seems to be on the blink again. Infirmary is in lockdown
@CMO on my way Julian
@chiefofops thanks! (see you at dinner, unless I end up in quarantine)
@CMO quarantine?
@chiefofops just got a faceful from an unsecured petri dish I’d been cultivating.
@CMO You ok??
@chiefofops should be in a few hours. Currently experiencing slight loss of motor-control, dizziness, enhanced aural sensitivity, tingling in my extremities, and everything seems to have gone quite a nice shade of pink. Not really the symptoms I was expecting at this stage but it’s a positive sign and all very interesting. Should be able to get at least one paper out of th(CHARACTER LIMIT REACHED)
@chiefofops…please could you tell Garak I won’t be able to meet him for lunch.
@chiefofops Chief?
@CMO stay where you are Julian I’ve got a situation on the promenade. Hang tight
***
@chiefofops Chief could you send another team to the Promenade?
@majorkira what is it Major?
@chiefofops some idiot in security left the doors to the office open. Odo and his bucket have floated out. Separately. Odo’s all over the Promenade
@majorkira uh oh
@chiefofopshe is NOT going to be happ
[@majorkira went offline]
@majorkira everything ok?
@majorkira Kira please respond
[@majorkira came online]
@chiefofops sorry Chief, just had to rescue a couple of vedeks from an unintentional anti -grav orb experience. Could have been messy. Jadzia’s here helping me now. All under control. We’ve got Odo back in his bucket
@chiefofops oh and chief Dax says to tell you not to worry about the voles
@majorkira voles??? I wasn’t worried but I am now. What’s she done?
***@WORF hey Worf you’re not answering your comm. Are you listening to opera? I know you’re off duty but we have an anti-grav situation over here, and could really use your help.
@dax I am on my way.
@WORF great! You can help me round up these floating voles/
@dax On second thoughts, I am very busy at present. I am needed on the Defiant. My apologies.
@WORF Worf you get over here right now and help me round up these voles or I guarantee I will throw you a surprise party for your next birthday
@dax I am on my way.
***
@dax Commander what’s happened with the voles?
@dax never mind, the nest just floated past. see you’re on the case. good work
@chiefofops thanks chief! I’d stay away from the infirmary if I were you, Julian’s got some sort of airborne plague in there.
@dax don’t I know it. Last thing we need is transmission by vole
***
@chiefofops URGENT URGENT GRAVITY MALFUNCTION IN THE BAR
@cometoquarks Quark please don’t use this channel, this is for senior staff only. Use @staff like everyone else.
@chiefofops did I mention this was URGENT
@cometoquarks A repair crew is currently assessing the situation on the Promenade.
@chiefofops the promenade?? You need to PRIORITIZE here. I have LATINUM on the CEILING
@cometoquarks Quark we’re working as fast as we can here. Your bar is NOT top priority.
@chiefofops not top priority??? Chief you don’t seem to understand, I have to look after my customers! Bad business is bad for everyone. They have a bad experience here, they report it back home, that could cause a diplomatic INCIDENT. You want that on your conscience??
@chiefofops also did I mention the LATINUM on the CEILING
@cometoquarks you’re not even our second priority
@chiefofops where’s my idiot brother?? why isn’t he fixing this??
@cometoquarks he’s helping to secure Odo
@chiefofops …Odo’s regenerating? Say no more. I completely understand. I have everything under control here, you just take your own sweet time
@cometoquarks Quark Odo is definitely going to review all the security footage after this. Whatever you’re thinking of doing, don’t.
@chiefofops you wound me, Chief. I thought we were friends. Your DARTS are floating around my bar. If they take someone’s eye out, YOU’RE paying for it.
***
@staff hi there, is there any reason why gravity seems to be functioning in the tailor’s shop, but not here? Only I can see his shop from my stall and it all looks fine in there. It’s chaos out here.
@jumalsjumja Hello Jumal this is Intern T’Pok. I have logged your case in our system. You are number #116 in the queue. Your request will be dealt with shortly. Thank you for your patience.

And then we got carried away and did some more:

Keep reading


Tags:

#Star Trek #DS9 #fanfic #anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog

treesided-triangle:

tumblr_inline_oub9o7faup1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9ol3vrs1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9ozbnuy1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9phfqap1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9pu4npj1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9q3lsaw1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9qboext1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9qkbrc41sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9r0irxg1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9rdy0rj1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9s7hgn71sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9sjryst1sastfq_540
tumblr_inline_oub9surwd01sastfq_540

Alex Hirsch is a treasure 


Tags:

#anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog #(normally I respect do-not-reblog notices) #(but the horse is long since out of the barn on this one and an additional reblog at this point won’t cause any more damage) #(and for that matter it wouldn’t show on Twitter’s metrics in any case)

keyla-lovely:

jimperbam:

thementalconfetti:

lesbianshepard:

lesbianshepard:

there’s an educational trivia game at the citadel on the exhibits on different planets called “Dog or Not?” that shows pictures of various four legged mammals and asks if they’re a breed of dog.

it was mainly for kids to learn about the diversity of earth’s flora and fauna but it became popular with adult aliens too and had to be shut down after almost causing no less than three diplomatic incidents.

they brought it to the nexus and it’s caused two more so far

“That’s definitely a dog.” “Incorrect. This is actually an animal called a ‘raccoon’” “What? No! It’s got the ears and the tail!”

“Okay, okay, I got this. That’s not a dog. It’s way too big it’s uhhh I think humans call them bears.” “Incorrect. This is a dog breed called a ‘newfoundland’” 

And when it becomes such a cultural obsession that they run tournaments and the final rounds are displayed live on the worldswide hologram system …

Somewhat cocky contestant (who heckles the others for wrong answers) looks at the hologram on display: “I’ve read up on a lot of Earth animals, even visited the Earth zoo, so you can’t fool me.  It’s a picture on a farm so that’s the first clue.  It’s white, fluffy, got a sloping forehead and no distinct… muzzle.. if I do remember the term correctly.  It’s most definitely a sheep.”  

Trivia host (attempting to hide their joy at finally being able to tell the contestant they’re wrong):  “I’m sorry, that is a dog called a Bedlington Terrier.  It is actually bred to look like a sheep, but notice the lack of keratinized tissue coverings on the extremities that make contact with the ground.  You missed quite an obvious difference there.”  (after the contestant stutters a bit and protests about dogs made specifically to look like not-dogs) “Let’s take it to the judges then” (after consulting small podium-top hologram of judging panel, now grinning and dripping with sarcasm) “Awwww…unfortunately it is a dog and rules of the game do not allow us to award partial credit… toooooo baaaaaad” (super cheerfully) “aaand… next image please!” 

Shepard loves “Dog or Not?”. The human crew never misses a tournament airing. They get it on a vid screen in the mess hall and all crowd around. Some people bring blankets and pillows. Some make snacks to share. Eventually it becomes like a Superbowl party.

Dog or Not becomes a sort of inside joke on the Normandy, one that the non-human crew members still kind of get – they’re always invited to the viewing parties and sometimes sit in – but don’t really understand. Tali especially doesn’t understand when a snickering Shepard elbows her and, pointing to a varren being taken for a walk, asks, “Hey, Tali – dog or not?”

“That’s…that’s a varren, Shepard,” Tali responds, bemused. “You know what a varren is.”

Shepard is still giggling, and Kaidan, who heard the exchange, joins in.

Liara, Ashley, and Shepard go to recover the lost data drive at Admiral Hackett’s request. They eventually find themselves surrounded by the strange monkey-looking organisms.

With a straight face, Ashley comments, “Wow, sure are a lot of dogs on this planet.”

Shepard doubles over. Liara isn’t sure whether or not to laugh. She’s watched “Dog or Not?” before, so she knows these creatures aren’t dogs…right?

Garrus accidentally joins in on the fun after they discover a new species on a fog-covered planet. They’re bright red, they have carapaces, and they breathe fire. The team is examining one’s corpse when Garrus asks hesitantly, “So…is that a dog?”

Shepard’s head whips up and they stare at him for a full five seconds before breaking down. Garrus has to half-carry a wheezing, crying Shepard back to the shuttle. Jack’s eyelashes are wet from her own mirth.

They’re driving full speed over the scorching desert of Tuchanka. They’ve just called Kalros, the mother of all thresher maws, to deal with the Reaper destroyer in their way. All faces are pressed to the windows to see the fight.

Kalros bursts from the sands with an unearthly screech and tackles the Reaper. The two grapple in the sands, both representing the might of organic and synthetic, respectively.

“Garrus,” Shepard says in a low, awed voice.

Garrus has been around Shepard for too long not to know when they’re about to make a joke. “Shepard, I swear on all the spirits of Palaven – “

“That’s the biggest dog I’ve ever seen.”

Garrus quietly regrets all his choices that led him to this moment, then sighs. “Which one?” he returns.

I have never played a Mass Effect game, yet this was very amusing.

@justice-turtle


Tags:

#Mass Effect #fanfic #anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog

Anonymous asked: I genuinely want to try to avoid using caste to refer to strangers but my language doesn’t have a singular caste-neutral pronoun, is there a standardized solution for this that I don’t know about or do I just have to deal with it?

{{deleted blog, username unknown}}:

You either have to deal with it or adopt colourless neopronouns. If your language doesn’t have an established colour-neutral pronoun, the constructed ones will probably be clunky and unnatural.

But even if I were writing to a monolingual audience, the core of my point wouldn’t be “don’t use coloured pronouns”. They’re a problem, but the problem isn’t one that’s fixed merely by adopting orthodox language. It takes some mindfulness to notice yourself rounding someone off to an instance of their caste, and to bring to mind other, unrelated things about them – but that’s really the core of it, the central tendency of what I miss in social justice.

 

tchtchtchtchtch:

“colourless pronouns”

have you ever heard of a more green idea

 

plain-dealing-villain:

#this makes me furious and I’m just gonna go to sleep now #shitpost #amenta#not sure this is even rp #linguistics inside joke #language


Tags:

#Amenta RP #(OP is roleplaying; I’m not) #Amenta #anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog #high context jokes #oh my god #language #(there’s at least one other post in my ”language” tag) #(where the punchline is ”colourless green ideas sleep furiously”) #(here’s another one for the collection)

stimmyabby:

autie-stereotype-crime-noir story

 

stimmyabby:

i like clues because they make sense, unlike people, who have legs that go on for days. how can a leg go on for days? i don’t know. help

 

stimmyabby:

i got the call late at night: “there’s been a murder on the orient express.” i knew i had to take the case immediately, because that is a TRAIN

 

stimmyabby:

i have been told i am “gritty” and “hardboiled”, maybe because i eat so many eggs and crunch the bits of shell between my teeth

 

stimmyabby:

“he’s the killer!” i said. “wait, no he’s not. wait, all these people look the same, which one is which again?”

 

stimmyabby:

i’m a straight shooter who plays by my own rules, all 376 of them that I have in this annotated binder

 

stimmyabby:

i’m a lose cannon, in fact, i have been institutionalized for erratic behavior

 

stimmyabby:

my job as a detective is made harder by the fact that i am physically incapable of telling a lie or bluffing but made easier by the fact that i have no emotions about anything but trains. once a train was murdered, and i couldn’t stop crying

 

stimmyabby:

she had curves in all the right places. i like curves, because they make sense, unlike people

 

stimmyabby:

i like my liquor hard, and my social interactions harder

 

stimmyabby:

i’m the best detective around, but my fees are high, and i only take payment in trains

 

stimmyabby:

she had curves in all the right places. she was a graph i was making about trains. in the other room, my dad was crying because i wouldn’t make eye contact with him

 

stimmyabby:

“you will tell me what i want.” i said. “everyone tells me what i want. i’m tough as nails, and i’m not afraid to display aggressive behavior”

 

stimmyabby:

i got into this job because one time in fifth grade i asked my special teacher why people don’t like me, and she told me to be a detective and figure it out. i took that completely literally, and here we are today

 

stimmyabby:

maybe i should throw away all my detective memorabilia so that i can hug my dad for the first time

 

stimmyabby:

“i know you’re a detective,” my mom sniffled, “but sometimes i feel like the real detective, trying to figure out how to finally help you”

 

stimmyabby:

the only mystery i cannot solve is the mystery of why these nice ladies keep making me play with special blocks. i have literally no theories about why this is happening

 

stimmyabby:

“i didn’t solve the case, and i let a second train get murdered!” i cried. “i’m a bad detective!” “oh, honey, no,” my mom soothed, “you’re not a bad detective, you’re just special, and sometimes that means things are a little bit harder for you”

 

stimmyabby:

he handed me the pictures of the suspects. i crossed out their eyes so i could look at their faces.

 

stimmyabby:

i got the call late at night. “TEXT ME” i shouted into the phone

 

stimmyabby:

“there’s been a terrible murder.” “that makes 231,” i said, twirling my hair. i like numbers.

 

stimmyabby:

she had curves that went on for legs. i reminded myself to make eye contact, like my special teacher told me

 

stimmyabby:

“ain’t she a beauty?” i asked. my special teacher had been working with me on saying “isn’t.” “a genuine Horse .75. i got her 12 years and 37 days ago and she weighs exactly 14 ounces. i call her Melissa, after my special teacher. she’s almost as good as a train.”

 

stimmyabby:

i took out my bottle of whiskey, and started to read the label aloud

 

stimmyabby:

i’m a private eye. that means i think eyes should be private. why do people have to look at each other’s eyes all the time?

 

stimmyabby:

the ceiling fan moved slowly in my grimy office, slowly like someone about to give up on the world. i stared up, up, up at it, distracted from my obsessive cleaning. it had curves in all the right places

 

stimmyabby:

the whole world seemed black and white, like an old film, or my thinking

 

stimmyabby:

i took my gun out of the pocket of my trench coat, which i was wearing because of my sensory issues

 

stimmyabby:

with my gun smashed​ to pieces on the floor and the criminal’s gun pointed right at me, it seemed like just about the right time to elope

 

maybesimon:

this is the best thing in the world


Tags:

#anything that makes me laugh this much deserves a reblog #autism #(it took me a while to understand that last one though) #(I think the joke is that the protagonist is using ”elope” to mean ”run away”) #(oblivious to the specifically marriage-related meaning it has in practice?)


{{next post in sequence}}