
thelethifoldwitch:
Question: Why can one not Finite Incantatem death when it has been magically caused?
Finite works on most things, does it not? Undoes a Transfiguration, undoes enchantments, charms, hexes, jinxes, at least to a point. Where Finite does not work there is a counter curse, counter jinx, counter spell in some form.
Question: Why is there no such thing for Avada Kedavra?
Because, you see, if there was, it would not truly be death. Death is not an effect, it is a state of being. To kill the soul must be torn from the body, and how can that be undone? A soul torn free must pass on, or linger as a fragmented ghost of memory, and a soul torn free cannot return to the body.
Death, you see, is not an effect. It is a state of being. It can be held off, but when it arrives, and we each of us shuffle off this mortal coil, it is final.
— Excerpt from Revised Dark Arts: Theory of the Dark by Oscar Jefferson.
(Image Source)
Ah, wizard separatism. Dude needs to talk to some Muggles about resuscitation.
(Well, I suppose this might be set in a time before Muggles started figuring out some of the more basic death-reversals, but this is the sort of thing that even a modern-day wizard separatist might say.)
Tags:
#Harry Potter #my father was dead once #he got better